It looks like whoever directed this tried as hard as they could to make a joke out of her...
Gigi Hadid and Bella Hadid
- Thread starter Tinyportia
- Start date
To a non average thinking person , her whole existence is a joke. . . A very bad DAD joke.
But yeah can someone take the concept and use it with some actual sexy models? Yes, in plural... Is for a friend
The botox didn't allowed her to make any facial expression. She was probably crying in the inside
By overwhelming demand, and with mixed emotions, I'm moving this out of Takedowns and into the Models section.
Should they each have their own thread?
Should they each have their own thread?
Maybe keep this one in Takedowns and give them their own threads in the Models section?
Definitely not, since traffic costs money and generates zero revenue. I messed around with an Amazon affiliates thing for guests but I've never seen a dime from it.
It's not entirely hidden but the thread contents are hidden.
My reason was that there was 100% agreement on this post from No One, and no alternate suggestions, so I assumed I was doing the will of the members.
No opinion either way; thought I was doing what y'all wanted. We could try @IcedAmericano's suggestion instead, but that seems like it could be confusing and weird.
I have to say I'd prefer them in the model section, but for different reasons than @NoOne's. Like it or not, they are two of the most successful models of the moment, and they both have worked hard to achieve the body they now have. They may never be our favorites, but credit where it's due is what i think.
On the other hand, I'd rather avoid guests that will lead us to the next Uptongate.
On the other hand, I'd rather avoid guests that will lead us to the next Uptongate.
My reason was that there was 100% agreement on this post from No One, and no alternate suggestions, so I assumed I was doing the will of the members.
This is only a guess but I feel like that post was made as more in the context of 'opening the eyes of the public with our takedown of the Hadid sisters and showing how terrible they are'- in this case it would still be a takedown but just a public one and therefore as @sore said, there would a risk of the Upton shitstorm again
Of course, this is just my interpretation and I am happy to do whatever the majority want.
I'm kinda happy this is public now, maybe people will realize how mediocre they are at modeling. Not judging their bodies but their faces which are obviously not model material.
As long as we can avoid the public outrage their fans may cause when they read our critique!! I'm petty, but the last thing I want is for the pair to gain sympathy because we discuss their negative qualities on this forum.
On the other hand, it'd be refreshing for people to access commentary that isn't sponsored ass-kssing content praising their absolute mediocrity.
On the other hand, it'd be refreshing for people to access commentary that isn't sponsored ass-kssing content praising their absolute mediocrity.
I'm torn. I hate everything about them, and all the BS around them. But at this point we can't really say they are not successful fashion models. Even though I wish they weren't.
I agree (sort of). I mean, if we measure success on their presence and campaign numbers alone then they're successful and we can't deny that.
I personally can't take them seriously knowing their careers were bought for them and have been/still are being sponsored by people who benefit handsomely from their constant media presence. They're in that strange new class of socialite-model that has had an easy road with very little adversity or rejection and that diminishes their success in my eyes.
I think it burns down to how we each define success in the industry. For me, anyone who benefits from family name and connections to the level the Hadids have - and anyone who purchases their entire face from a surgeon - isn't on par success wise with the actually talented, beautiful and hard working ladies in the industry.
I think it's all just a matter of perception and personal standards, plus I'm someone without much industry knowledge so my definition of success is entirely opinion based.
Motion to call them "successful It Girls"? Or "successful products of nepotism"? Successful...just anything but fashion model.
Nobody can argue with the success. But I cannot mentally put these two on the level of natural, hardworking, talented beauties like Natalia and Vlada.
Edit: I also generally disagree with suddenly making threads public. Sometimes I disclose things in members-only sections of the forum that I wouldn't say if I knew the entire Internet could access them easily.
I'm not questioning their success or how they look, because body wise, they definitely do not deserve the takedown section anymore (Bella more than Gigi) and they're really in demand career wise. But there is already a Gigi Hadid thread in the model section, we could've just made a singular one for Bella aswell? Cara Delevingne looks pretty good now too but she's still in the takedowns and I feel like most people here tolerate here more than the Hadids. They haven't been fat for a little over six months now and the thread still never turned into a positive one so idk. I feel like it's just asking for negative attention & more trolls on the forum