Models: Before & After Weight Gain (or Loss)

eliza88

Grand Dame
Joined
Feb 19, 2020
Posts
382
Karma
2,346
Tragedy. Holly Rose Emery.

She apparently went from overweight to very thin a good decade ago, but now has basically reverted back to overweight because she has “become a woman” (quotes from her interview).

I really cannot grasp how these people need to go from skinny to EXTREMELY FAT. There’s no in between anymore?

You can’t get to that size without eating something like 4000-5000 consistently everyday. Even if she ate a normal amount of 2000, she would still be average weight and not overweight like this.

I get you feel deprived from maintaining skinny, but then eat junk for a week then. Gain 10 pounds then and lose it again.
Why go so so overboard and gain sooooo much of weight? Can’t wrap my head around it. Now she’s stuck in an overweight body when she could look so good.

Before:

19626902-16C7-43AA-AEFB-22327A102077.jpeg9A7C45D5-0A4F-4180-93DF-FB7373F732FF.jpeg

A555C2F9-2369-48FA-815C-AEC33CD546C8.jpeg

66318C6E-8876-42B2-8FE9-81CB0FBFD406.jpeg

After:

87C5ECFA-92B8-40D6-94B8-2EEB9442B9AB.jpeg

73013090-4390-496E-8886-625E57E422F9.jpeg

AF26B9E6-D72A-4B37-A03B-275D25637530.jpeg

52261765-0070-4864-B7B2-DD6FA354827B.jpeg

1E11A082-4C36-4870-848C-362E41C62C76.jpeg
 
  • Sad
  • Gross
  • Agree
Reactions: 16 users

Marinamarilou

Super Star
Joined
Nov 26, 2020
Posts
219
Karma
1,463
Tragedy. Holly Rose Emery.

She apparently went from overweight to very thin a good decade ago, but now has basically reverted back to overweight because she has “become a woman” (quotes from her interview).

I really cannot grasp how these people need to go from skinny to EXTREMELY FAT. There’s no in between anymore?

You can’t get to that size without eating something like 4000-5000 consistently everyday. Even if she ate a normal amount of 2000, she would still be average weight and not overweight like this.

I get you feel deprived from maintaining skinny, but then eat junk for a week then. Gain 10 pounds then and lose it again.
Why go so so overboard and gain sooooo much of weight? Can’t wrap my head around it. Now she’s stuck in an overweight body when she could look so good.

Before:

View attachment 106061View attachment 106062

View attachment 106063

View attachment 106064

After:

View attachment 106065

View attachment 106066

View attachment 106067

View attachment 106068

View attachment 106069
Holy shoot, her cheeks look so unhealthy. Her teint. I mean there's people with that colour naturally but since she didn't seem to have it before, I assume it's the same red cheeks that obese people with cardiac problems often get. Mostly caused by eating too much red meat and unhealthy fats. She must not only eat giant amounts of foods, but literally only extremely unhealthy ones... Sad to see
 
  • Agree
Reactions: 1 users

Jamie123x

Rising Star
Joined
Nov 10, 2020
Posts
98
Karma
510
I will never be able to understand the sentiment of giving up something like that in exchange for short term reward of food with detrimental health issues in the long run. Granted, if it's done un an unsustainable way then she might fool herself into thinking she's feeling better being fat (not just her, applicable to a lot in this thread) but then you clearly took the wrong approach and are lacking education.

Even if you do decide that a rather disciplined lifestyle is not for you and fail to integrate 'SG habits' into your life and would rather follow mainstream masses and fit into the norm, fine - your choice.
But she does NOT look healthy. The way the weight is distributed, the fact that it just looks like layers of fat without any muscle definition what so ever, the bloated face and cheeks, hollow eyes + swollen eyelids, she does not embody the ideal of a 'normal healthy' weight either. And spiraling back and forth between two extremes? Terrible, mentally and physically.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: 7 users

eliza88

Grand Dame
Joined
Feb 19, 2020
Posts
382
Karma
2,346
I will never be able to understand the sentiment of giving up something like that in exchange for short term reward of food with detrimental health issues in the long run.

Even if you do decide that a rather disciplined lifestyle is not for you and fail to integrate 'SG habits' into your life and would rather follow mainstream masses and fit into the norm, fine - your choice.

What I don’t understand is the need for extremism.

I actually understand it completely that people do not want to be SG skinny. It’s difficult and going against the grain.
But why the extremism in weight gain? Surely it must be EQUALLY difficult to be stuffing yourself with 5000 calories a day??
You are just trading one “disordered eating” for another except the trade off sucks, because now you have a fat body that comes with it.

These body positivity people are hiding their binge eating disorders or other types of disordered eating through advocating Body Positivity.

Disordered eating is so much more prevalent amongst the masses ( amongst the body building community/ the fat movement community etc) , but people ONLY EVER CALL OUT the super skinny when they talk about disordered eating.

It is absolutely frustrating!
 
  • Like
  • Agree
Reactions: 13 users

natalie-katie

Rising Star
Joined
Aug 17, 2020
Posts
91
Karma
703
Location
Sweden
What I don’t understand is the need for extremism.

I actually understand it completely that people do not want to be SG skinny. It’s difficult and going against the grain.
But why the extremism in weight gain? Surely it must be EQUALLY difficult to be stuffing yourself with 5000 calories a day??
You are just trading one “disordered eating” for another except the trade off sucks, because now you have a fat body that comes with it.

These body positivity people are hiding their binge eating disorders or other types of disordered eating through advocating Body Positivity.

Disordered eating is so much more prevalent amongst the masses ( amongst the body building community/ the fat movement community etc) , but people ONLY EVER CALL OUT the super skinny when they talk about disordered eating.

It is absolutely frustrating!

I agree with this, and what also makes me frustrated is that these people are eating for two (or more). They are eating as if they were feeding two adult women while normalizing it because they are body positive or whatever reason they might have.

Trying to justify their gluttony while people are starving and the earth is dying is, to me, egoistic and unethical in so many ways. I actually feel deep sadness for the humanity and for the environment.

I can’t imagine this opinion would be well received in other communities. Luckily, I believe you here on SG can understand my feelings which is a little comforting at least :luv:
 
  • Agree
  • Like
Reactions: 10 users

aestheticallyskinny

Community Duchess
Joined
Apr 26, 2020
Posts
575
Karma
3,993
Location
Paris
I wouldn't necessarily post her weight gain since she openly spoke about her Eating Disorder. She even
addressed that "getting healthy is not letting yourself go".

 
  • Agree
  • Like
Reactions: 9 users

angel baby

Super Star
Joined
May 30, 2021
Posts
159
Karma
1,536
Location
Europe
I wouldn't necessarily post her weight gain since she openly spoke about her Eating Disorder. She even
addressed that "getting healthy is not letting yourself go".

Omg I didn't know... I feel kinda bad now. But I mean, she posts pictures of her body so I'd guess she is fine with her appearance? I don't know much about eating disorders but I'll try be careful with such things.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 9 users

luciole

Super Star
Joined
Dec 13, 2017
Posts
563
Karma
1,402
Location
NYC
Omg I didn't know... I feel kinda bad now. But I mean, she posts pictures of her body so I'd guess she is fine with her appearance? I don't know much about eating disorders but I'll try be careful with such things.
I wouldn’t equate sharing images of your body as confidence but I hope that’s the case here
 
  • Agree
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users

Tinyportia

SkinnyGossip Royal
Joined
Aug 1, 2013
Posts
3,006
Karma
13,212
Location
Australia
I came across some old photos of Magdalena from the very start of her modelling career and couldn't believe how chubby she used to be.

These runway photos are from S/S 2006 and F/W 2006 fashion weeks, and an editorial shot from around the same time.

Before1.jpgBefore2.jpgBefore3.jpgBefore4.jpgBefore5.jpg

She obviously got her shit together after F/W 2006, because here she is just six months later during S/S 2007. Quite an impressive transformation in a (relatively) short period of time.

After1.jpgAfter2.jpgAfter3.jpgAfter4.jpgAfter5.jpg
 
  • Like
  • Love
  • Jizztastic
Reactions: 14 users

eliza88

Grand Dame
Joined
Feb 19, 2020
Posts
382
Karma
2,346
I always thought Kelsey Merritt from Victoria Secret was always big. Never came across a skinny version of her since she joined VS.

Surprisingly, she was a decent size way back when she modeled in the Philippines. How sad she decided to become “curvy” and “sexy”.

Notice how her vibe, pose and presentation after the weight gain is sexy, pouty and sultry while when she was skinny, it was invariably high fashion and fierce even though her lips were still very full.

She had more appeal when she was skinny even though her face never struck me to be anything more than commercial.

Now:

4C238157-8BE7-451F-BF99-CA8243C985B8.jpeg756C2AED-FD21-4CDF-8DC0-9FA549047FAF.jpegF35100DF-9AA8-4FCF-A2AF-102B3C19B07F.jpeg2A626BA0-FC82-4739-A1AE-670B7733C318.jpeg1CCED71B-2070-46F8-919B-81835FD8EFB7.jpeg

Before:

9F0D05AE-1CEE-443A-B117-18D0477503A8.jpeg6270E20C-9D8E-4259-AB02-E15673AA6C11.jpeg972B0187-E1FC-434F-BA9D-914D58174654.jpegCEC92AB0-C369-4F7A-8330-20901AC9CCF8.jpegD5CADED0-4F20-47FB-8A27-A806EB407415.jpeg
 
  • Sad
  • Agree
Reactions: 8 users

nav16

Grand Dame
Joined
May 24, 2021
Posts
146
Karma
1,964
Location
USA
Jess Picton-Warlow
Before:
jess_before(1).jpeg
jess_before(2).jpeg


After:
jess_after(1).jpeg
jess_after(2).jpegjess_after (3).jpeg
jess_after(4).jpeg
 
  • Love
  • Like
Reactions: 16 users

Sweetpotato

Rookie
Joined
Jan 15, 2020
Posts
34
Karma
121
Location
US
Of course the comments are giving her the validation she’s looking for, “you’re not even plus size now, you’re so beautiful and healthy!”
 
  • Sad
Reactions: 8 users