Dunno, I reposted something in the Kasia Struss thread the other day (they were pictures taken by a member here so this was the source) and someone replied with 'skinny gossip.. :ninja:' so it seems like members there don't like it.
tFS have banned weight talk throughout the entire site, as well as drug talk. There used to be one dedicated thread for weight talk about models and celebrities but then that too was closed. I think the focus upon weight talk on SG is the issue, but the tFS mods are so strict about it there that everyone's a little hypersensitive about the subject. You'll often see in a model's thread that someone will post "oh where has she been lately, she didn't walk Paris..?", and someone else will say "I believe for reasons we are unable to discuss and anyway how's the weather oh what a wunnerful day!!!1!", haha!
I joined many, many (many!) years ago and also wish it wasn't so commercial as it is now, but it's still invaluable and THE place for fashion talk.
I only go there to bring over the models pic to SGF. I remember the weight talk threads - I never believed the 'concerned' posts about very skinny models. (to be honest the weight thread wouldn't make sense anymore -> there are like 5 superskinny models left, the rest would be the usual media influenced 'got scary thin' mode)...