Of course because it's a mental illness it's more complicated, I just meant that while she may feel fat when she has gained weight (I think her gw is 45 kg?), other recovered anorexics actually are fat. Here I was thinking of a former classmate who was anorexic, I saw her lately after 2 years, and she's very chubby and doesn't look as good as she did when she was anorexic, but she was sick and she needed to recover. I'm happy that she's healthy again, but I know her and I know that it's hard for her to be so chubby.
I edited my post a bit to make more sense , so perhaps it gets my point over more clearly now, but I think the general gist of what I'm saying is that the reality of an anorexic person's weight status is probably less influential on their recovery than their ability to disentangle their sense of self from their weight, whatever it is.
Please forgive me for pushing the point; I suppose the reason why it means something to me is that I thought your post could perhaps be read as saying 'Yeah, well, she might have succeeded in conquering her life-threatening mental illness or whatever, but AT LEAST SHE'S NOT FAT!!'; I also found your assertion that 'recovering anorexics actually are fat' maybe a bit of a generalisation, if you're only actually referring to one person, and I suppose I feel worried about generalisations that might confuse people on this issue. I'm sure that's not at all what you meant, but I guess just the idea of that thought triggered me a little. I could definitely be being over-sensitive though, and can only really talk about how I feel about weight gain. Let's hope it's easier for Nancy.